It’s understandable, given our history. “All men are created equal” has been a point of noisy, bloody contention from the beginning.
But in an America that’s radically different from the slave-holding, immigrant-bashing nation of the past, is constant vigilance against ethnic offense always a good thing?
As this classic 2002 article from Reason‘s Tim Cavanaugh points out, our industriousness extends beyond cars, steel or hamburgers. We’re also pretty good at manufacturing bad feelings toward each other under the well-intentioned rubric of “anti-discrimination.”
Some good points from the article:
- “Call it the anti-defamation industry, the anti-discrimination lobby, or maybe the umbrage market.”
- “An anti-discrimination group has little motive to report improvement, or even stasis, in cultural relations, because that would lessen the perceived need for the group.”
- “This may explain why anti-discrimination is a growth industry even — or especially — while identity politics fades into history, more Americans decline to identify themselves by ethnicity, and actual discrimination is, by virtually all measures, at historically low levels.”
The piece is long, but well worth your time.